Taken as a set phrase, “the exception that proves the rule” indicates a deviation from the norm, a challenge to the stereotype. It says, in effect, the norm or stereotype is the rule and here is something that is an exception to that rule. – mental_floss blog, September 16, 2013.
I have to say that I love exceptions – and I’m not sure if they prove the rule, but I like the one guy NOT doing what everyone else is doing, which proves… well, that stereotypes aren’t always true…
A ferinstance: TSA people, border patrol, and customs agents: we all love to hate them (and apologies if you are one, or live with one, or whatever). Since probably October of 2001, they’ve been the people we’ve seen at the forefront of the thankless job of protecting the borders of our country and keeping us safe, for a given value of the word. We’ve seen them reviled in the press and in reality – sometimes deservedly so, sometimes unjustifiably. Travel is simply overly-stressful anyway, what with being sealed into a metal tube with strangers, hurtling through the atmosphere. Add to it the unpleasantness of abrupt, rude people who have a right to touch you, and — wow.
Going through the airports this last time was unnerving – the attitudes of some of the working folk toward those visiting the U.S. for the first time… wow. We LIKE tourists, guys, let’s not forget that. I wanted to put sticky notes on various desks as I passed, “Remember: just because they’re not from this country doesn’t make them Automatically Evil.” To me, the firm and invasive pat-downs, having my hair gone through — really?! I know my snake used to like to hunt through and pull out my pins, but I apparently now have that super-thick updo that needs to be raked through — and being stopped even after clearing the little metal detector with no alarm — those were minor issues, compared to the questions I heard from the people who were pulled aside. “Where did you meet? Who were you visiting?” Hearing the stories from some of our UK friends was disheartening as well, of people being asked to open laptops and show emails to prove where they were going, to being shouted at, and reduced to tears, etc. etc. etc. — So, TSA/Border/Security Agents = boogeymen, yes? And then, you get another view.
There was a NASTY guy working the lines last Saturday night. Maybe he was upset about not being out with friends. Maybe he had a headache. I have NO idea, but his blistering sarcasm made our entire line flinch. People who watched the Canadian-American couple he spoke harshly to whispered among themselves, and frowned. He was flat out mean. As we neared the head of the line where he was pre-examining paperwork and passports, we tensed, ready for his pseudo-friendly and invasive questions to turn nasty and sly. Fortunately, he was called away – maybe it was well past time for him to get something to eat? — and for awhile, our line stalled, shuffling in place as there was a snafu with a fingerprint scanner. At the crowd’s collective quiet groan – it was a seriously long line – the agent at the booth stood and graciously directed the woman to another, and our line moved forward.
When it was our turn, we shuffled forward.
“And how are you doing?” the agent asked courteously.
“Tired,” Tech Boy responded dully, thrusting forward his paperwork.
The agent glanced up. “And, would it be totally rude of me to say you look it?” he asked pleasantly.
We burst into startled laughter.
And that’s how our entire interaction went – he made jokes the whole time, and we left giggling. He was like a friendly, dorky neighbor you already know. He was, unexpectedly, nice. Exhausted and wobbly and filthy and grim, to us, he was a gift.
And amusingly, a day later, I saw Kate Beaton’s little sketch about her adventure with a border agent, and I thought, Yeah. They get a bad rap. Sometimes it’s deserved, like when one tried to separate my wheelchair-bound little sister from my mother to frisk her in a room alone when she was only nine, or the ones who made mothers drink breast milk, and the one who once shook a misbehaving little kid (unfortunately true story – Tech Boy’s coworker was dogpiled after someone shook his child and he reacted badly). Sometimes the phrase “absolute power corrupts absolutely” FULLY applies to these folks. Fortunately, no one group is all one anything – no one is all bad.
And, this is the kind of thing that brings me a secret, quiet happy, as I travel – the Rules blare out – don’t touch abandoned luggage. Report suspicious looking people. Don’t run with scissors! (Okay, maybe not that last one.) And, human kindness still exists in bad jokes, shared exasperated smiles, and helping someone else shove their luggage into the increasingly tiny overhead compartments.
The magic of travel can really be leached out before you actually get anywhere, but finding little kindnesses – and paying them forward along the way – really makes a difference.
And for these exceptions, I give thanks.

Your TSA guy sounds like a hoot! My underwire usually ensures that I get a friendly greeting from the agents. Already gearing up mentally for my Christmas flights.